Nevertheless, the day was GREAT. For those of you who don't know, I attended "Intelligent Design: The Scientific, Theological and Civil Dimensions of the Debate" at E-town College, an all-day event. Yup. I skipped school. =)
First in the ring were the two biologists: Dr. Michael Behe (pronounced Beehee), Professor of Biochemistry at Lehigh University and author of the book Darwin's Black Box: The Biochemical Challenge to Evolution, and Dr. Niall (pronounced Neal) Shanks, Professor of Philosophy, and Adjunct Professor of both Biological Sciences and Physics and Astronomy at East Tennessee State University, and author of God, the Devil, and Darwin: A Critique of Intelligent Design Theory. First to the plate was Behe. I think everyone can agree that Behe put on a stellar presentation. Very professional in his systematic arguement for the case of an intelligent designer. Using a PowerPoint presentation, the self-proclaimed Christian argued that there are simply questions in which science can not answer. Evolution is just as much - if not more - of a "speculation" or imagining. Behe compares this to Calvin and Hobbes, as Calvin, often not knowing how things actually work, uses his own imagination. For example, Behe showed a Bill Waterson drawing of Calvin and Hobbes flying in a cardboard box. Calvin didn't know how planes work, so he speculated that all you must just need something with flaps, or "wings" such as a cardboard box! So it is with Darwinists who have not a clue how certain things couldn't have evolved (they admit to it themselves), so therefore they "imagine" what could've happened. He argued that iit is indeed the opposite of popular persuasion that intelligent design is simply the cop-out of unanswered questions. Against popular opinion, as science progresses, it does not prove itself more, but in fact leaves more unopened questions. For example, 30 years ago, Darwinism was much more believable, but now that more detail has been unveiled about cells, for example, Darwinism becomes more and more irrational and illogical. Whereas conversely, intelligent design continually increases in legit and rational. Behe used the analogy of Mt Rushmore. If one were to put a veil over the faces of Mt Rushmore, than one might easily induce that, indeed, this mountain was simply made by natural causes: plate tectonics, for example. However, pull the veil away a little so that an ear may appear. Ok, that's a little odd, one may think. But nevertheless, it must have just been coincidental. This, for example, may have been where we were in science 50 years ago. However, let's take the veil away a little more. Suddenly, an entire face is evident! And another one! And another one! As the veil is gradually removed more and more, revealing the intricacy and precision in the making of the faces, it becomes absurd, proposterous, and downright asinine to assume that such an artistic, complicated masterpiece simply was made by something as random as plate tectonics. No! It must have been made by an intelligent designer. Even a foreigner, or a child, who may never have heard of Mt Rushmore, would be able to induce such a logical conclusion. So it is analogous with biology. As more and more is revealed and uncovered about cells, their complexity and itricacies, it becomes downright foolishness to claim that everything simply randomly and chaotically evolved. Behe's main argument he refers to as "irreducible complexity." He defines it as thus:
A single system composed of several well-matched, interacting parts that contribute to the basic function, wherein the removal of any one of the parts causes the system to effectively cease functioning. An irreducibly complex system cannot be produced directly (that is, by continuously improving the initial function, which continues to work by the same mechanism) by slight, successive modifications of a precursor system, because any precursor to an irreducibly complex system that is missing a part is by definition nonfunctional.
Thus, debunking the theory of Darwinian evolution and natural selection. He used an example such as a bacterial flagellum.
Behe's point was all the more powerful when he presented the rebuttles of his famous critic, a notorious, world-renown MIT biologist Russel Doolittle. Using the example of bloood clots, Behe proved that if just one out of somewhere around 12 or 14 genes were taken out of the equation, the entire process of clotting would malfunction, resulting in MAJOR complications of the body (i.e. the body would be so stiff that one could not move, for just one of the many examples!) I wish I could show the diagram in his book, but I can't find a copy of it on the internet at all. I'd like to show how VERY COMPLEX it really is. Anyway, Doolittle - admitted by Behe to probably be the world's most knowledgeable scientist on the study of clotting - refuted Behe's claim by citing an experiment done on mice. He says that the experiment proved that actually the mice are quite capable of surviving without multiple genes associated in the clotting system known as cascade:
"Knockout mice" are now a common (but expensive) tool in the armamentarium of those scientists anxious to cure the world's ills. Recently the gene for plaminogen was knocked out of mice, and, predictably, those mice had thrombotic complications because fibrin clots could not be cleared away. Not long after that, the same workers knocked out the gene for fibrinogen in another line of mice. Again, predictably, these mice were ailing, although in this case hemorrhage was the problem. And what do you think happened when these two lines of mice were crossed? For all practical purposes, the mice lacking both genes were normal! Contrary to claims about irreducible complexity, the entire ensemble of proteins is not needed. Music and harmony can arise from a smaller orchestra.
Here's the problem: Behe pointed something out very essential. Doolittle must have only read the title to the lab paper: Loss of fibrinogen rescues mice from the pleiotropic effects of plasminogen deficiency. Apparently he must have seen the word "rescues" and didn't even bother to read the rest of the article. Here's why. Behe rebuttles by saying:
The implied argument appears to be that the cited work shows the clotting system is not irreducibly complex, so a simpler clotting cascade might be something like the one that lacked plasminogen and fibrinogen, which could be expanded into the modern clotting system by gene duplication. Perhaps there are other stable systems of lesser complexity, and the entire cascade could then be built up by small steps in what is thought to be the typical Darwinian pattern. However, that interpretation depends on a mistaken reading of Bugge et al. (1996).Ok. Let's put this in laymen's term. What Doolittle is saying is this: the experiment on the mice found this: Take gene A out of the mice, and you have negative symptoms x, y, and z. Take just gene B out of other mice, and you have negative symptons m, n, and o. HOWEVER, Doolittle claims that the experiment discovered that if you cross the lines of both mice, then the subsequent mice that missing genes A and B are actually "normal!" Behe's rebuttle is this: the actual report says otherwise! The actual report says that what was discovered was that when mice are missing gene A and B, they "only" have neagative symptons m, n, and o. What the title of the article was claiming was that "loss of [gene B] 'rescues' mice from effects of [gene A] deficiency." Therefore, to be specific, these mice still have these negative symptons: "they do not form clots, they hemorrhage, and the females die if they become pregnant."
Bugge et al. (1996) note that the lack of plasminogen in mice "results in high mortality, wasting, spontaneous gastrointestinal ulceration, rectal prolapse, and severe thrombosis. Furthermore, plasminogen-deficient mice display delayed wound healing following skin injury." On the other hand, if the gene for fibrinogen is knocked out, the result is failure to clot, frequent hemorrhage, and that "pregnancy uniformly results in uterine bleeding around the tenth day of gestation." (Suh et al. 1995) The point of Bugge et al. (1996) was that if one crosses the two knockout strains, producing plasminogen-plus-fibrinogen deficiency in individual mice, the mice do not suffer the many problems that afflict mice lacking plasminogen alone. Since the title of the paper emphasized that mice are "rescued" from some ill-effects, one might be misled into thinking that the double-knockout mice were normal. They are not. As Bugge et al. (1996) state in their abstract, "Mice deficient in plasminogen and fibrinogen are phenotypically indistinguishable from fibrinogen-deficient mice." In other words, the double-knockouts have all the problems that mice lacking only fibrinogen have: they do not form clots, they hemorrhage, and the females die if they become pregnant. They are definitely not "[f]or all practical purposes . . . normal." (Doolittle 1997) (Table 1)
Hmm....sound normal? If it is, I sure hope that I'm strange!
So Behe's point was this: the most knowledgeable man in the entire world for bloood clots still can't efficiently argue Behe's point of irreducible complexity for clotting. How can we deducibly conclude, then, that through natural selection, it just happened to randomly evolve?
Altogether, Behe's argument was excellent. It was very coherent, understandable, empirical, systematic, and logical. Behe was very entertaining as well, with a hilarious dry sense of humor, including some very funny, light-hearted, self-deprecating remarks.
Next in line was his opponent, Dr. Niall Shanks. Ok, I promise that I approached this with an open-mind, and tried to be as unbiased as possible. But Mr. Shank's presentation was immediately unappealing. Let me first point out that the man was indubitably nervous. Not just nervous - I was afraid sometimes that I'd he'd peal over with a heart attack. This man seemed nerve-racked! He was scared stiff, and it was obvious. And I'm confident that iit was because Behe just completed a stellar presentation for intelligent design. Completely unnerved, he immediately began dropping his papers as he put them on the podium. As he bent over to pick them up, his hands were violently shaking. I'm not exaggerating one bit. Multiple people I talked to afterwords observed the same condition. (And it's not as if it was some health problem he had: he did not continue doing in the entire time.) When Behe presented, he did not begin checking his watch until near the end of his presentation, simply in order to figure out if he'd have to cut anything short to fit everything into the approximate 45-minute time slot for his presentation. However, I noticed that Shanks began checking his watch only 5 minutes into the presentation! Surely, I thought, he can't be that unprepared that he's already worried that he'll have enough material. Nevertheless, I must admit that he did spend his entire slotted time presenting his argument. However, his argument was utterly incoherent, unsystematic, illogical, and replete with randomness. In addition, althought entirely irrelevant to the actual debate between Darwinism and Intelligent Design, I must add that his presentation via overhead (because he "didn't do PowerPoint"), was much more unappealing, unimpressive, and slightly unprofessional (at least in view of Behe's very sophisticated PowerPoint presentation). The childish picture drawing weren't that helpful either. (And although slightly humorous, not nearly as effective as Behe's dry humor).
All in all, I honestly didn't follow Shanks argument (I really did approach it unbiased, and other people had the same thoughts as myself). Nevertheless, he did a MUCH more impressive job on the impromtu 10-minute rebuttal and subsequent Q&A with the crowd. He seemed much more confident and calm. Even so, overall, I think Behe smoked him in the debate. I just wish Dr. Davidson and Dr. Kearns could've been there to have smoked Shanks as well with questions!
After lunch, (and a very pleasant conversation with Amanda Iriana, which consisted of telling her everything I know about Peru! in order to prepare her for when she goes this year for the first time!), we headed back to the chapel in order to witness the second round of debate: the theological discussion. Beginning the debate was......yours truly, Pastor Dave!!!! Or, "Reverend Martin". Hehe. I don't have much to say about his debate. It was actually very good. He focused on three things: 1) What is evangelicalism (since it's such a driving force behind the push for intelligent design being taught in classrooms), 2) What is the role for intelligent design in the classroom, and finally 3) the theological reasons (or implications, depending on which direction you start from) for intelligent design. To be brutally honest, he actually got the longest applause out of all 6 debaters throughout the day. I don't know why, but nothing really comes to mind though of particular note-worthiness.
Following Dave was Dr. John Haught, Thomas Healey Professor of Theology at Georgetown University, and author of Deeper than Darwin: The Prospects for Religion in the Age of Evolution and God after Darwin: A Teology of Evolution. Uh.......this guy was a load of crock. I'm sorry, but talk about some screwed up theology. Basically, he was a Darwinist, trying to weezle religion in there (Ok, I admit, many people label us as Creationists trying to somehow fit science in). But nevertheless, this guy used a philosophical argument with a deity involved more than he used Scripture. I understand that Scripture probably is the illogical thing to use when debating a scientist about evolution. But this was a theological debate. He barely used any Scripture, at least for his main points (only a few, rather irrelevant - or so it seemed - points). He basically referred to "Providence" more than he did a Christian God. And this is what really caught my attention: He addressed the question: "If there was an intelligent designer, why'd he make everything so screwed up? Why is there so much suffering?" His response? He in turn asked us if we were in the position of the intelligent designer, what kind of world would we make? A perfect, yet insipid and monotonous world? Or an imperfect world, replete with suffering, but nevertheless exciting? His view: imperfect = exciting, and is therefore better than a perfect world.....????? Yes, folks. Dr. Haught proposed an imperfect world being better than a perfect world. He made the state of perfection out to be negative! No matter what your religious beliefs are, that's the most proposterous, irrational, unplausible, truth-denying claim I've ever heard! Give me a break. There is a myriad of theological questions I'd love to nail him with (Do you actually think heaven then is now, being in a state of imperfection? What would the post-resurrected life of perfection be then? What about the curse of the ground due to original sin, resulting in imperfection and chaos? The glorified, metaphorical city of Jerusalem in Revelation, which is described as beautiful after all chaos and imperfection has been demolished? Jesus claim to be the Prince of Peace? The propitiator? ) Anyway, theological aspects aside, I'd like to ask him to try and explain that in a philosophical/historical view: If imperfection is "exciting" and thus better, why does every culture in history strive for a state of perfection? What does Marxism strive for? Why did Thomas More right Utopia? Why did the religiously persecuted seek freedom and theocratic rule in the New World? Why does half the world cry for peace in any and every situation, no matter the implications? And Dr. Haught, I'd pay to see you look in the eyes of victims of atrocity, and tell them a state of imperfection is better cause it's "exciting"! Lemme round up a few family members of 9/11 vicitims. Or a few homeless, family-less tsunami victims in Southeast Asia. Or how about Kosovo refugees? How about you look straight in the eyes of a victim of the atrocities and s in the Sudan? Apartheid victims? Family members of the victims of the BTK serial killer? Laci Peterson's parents? The list goes ON and ON! Would you have the audacity, Dr. Haught, to tell any of the victims of the aforementioned inhumanity and depravity that they should rejoice because life is "exciting"? Wow.....that's audacious to even consider....completely apathetic and ignorant to their very real torment and anguish of life.
Wow.
Somehow liberal theology sounds much more inhumane and uncompassionate than evangelical convervatism.
So then were the rebuttals and Q&A's. Not much noteworthy, except Haught completely avoided Seth Girard's question of original sin.....such a politician's answer of dancing around the question.
After pretty much everyone from our church left (except the tough and proud), came probably the most interesting debate of all......Basically it was a preview of the Dover School District case. Richard Thompson, president and chief council of the Thomas More Law Center representing the Dover Area School District, versus Witold "Vic" Walczak, legal director of the Greater Pittsburg Chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union (yes, the ACLU! Ah! Swear word! Sorry!) Foundation of Pennyselvania, and lead attorney in the prosecution against the Dover Area School District in the federal lawsuit. Yes, ladies and gentlemen, first I'll say: I saw an ACLU lawyer in person. It was the first time I ever saw one those things in person. I'm almost inclined to argue the theory of evolution when I see one of those things (known as an ACLU lawyer. Is it a person with a soul? We're still trying to figure that out....hehe).
Certainly though, this was the most controversial and passionate debate of the day! I must admit, this is the area I have the most trouble arguing for. That is, the civil implications of intelligent design, as a whole. Not the case of Kitzmiller et al. v. Dover Area School District .
"Darwin's Theory is a theory, it continues to be tested as new evidence is discovered. The Theory is not a fact. Gaps in the Theory exit for which there is no evidence. A theory is defined as a well-tested explanation that unifies a broad range of observations.
First, I'll say why I don't see that there's any problem in the Dover School case. All they simply decided was require that at the begining of the course, teachers read a short, 1-minute statement, reminding students that
"Darwin's Theory is a theory, it continues to be tested as new evidence is discovered. The Theory is not a fact. Gaps in the Theory exit for which there is no evidence. A theory is defined as a well-tested explanation that unifies a broad range of observations."And then, it is stated that intelligent design is another possibility, and if a child is interested, there is a book availabe for more information. That's it. (you can read the whole thing here) Ok, and this quote is taken directly from the Dover Area School District Press Release on their website:
The Superintendent, Dr. Richard Nilsen, has directed that no teacher will teach Intelligent Design, Creationism, or present his or her, or the Board’s, religious beliefs.
Ok, now ACLU prosecuting attorney Witold "Vic" Walczak is quoted as