OK, so sorry I haven't posted for a while. I haven't really been home much.
So last Wednesday I got out of school early to leave for Philly with my political science class (by the way, I figured out that in a span of 6 school days, I only spent 13.5 half hours in school between delays, early dismissals, and missing school for various events...how cool is that!?). After riding in a coach bus, we arrived in Philly later that afternoon. First stop was touring the new
Constitution Center. Wow. Quality presentation, if I may say so, myself. The opening presentation - a breed of live drama with cinema - was
amazing. Top of the line. My utter respect goes out to the guy who narrarated. I don't know how long it took him to memorize that, and be able to time his narrative perfectly with the special effects! The actual displays were very well done, as well. Everything was top of the line, interactive, and very fun and informative at the same time. After that we went to the
Liberty Bell. (Later, I found out
somebody decided to bring pot on the trip, and didn't know what to do when we had to go through a security checkpoint, and she had it in her purse, which had to go through the x-ray machine! I don't know how she ever got through....but yea, some people really don't think....) Later we went on a tour of
Independence Hall, where the
Declaration of Independence was adopted, and the
Constitution was debated, drafted, and signed. Nothing very noteworthy happened during the tour. But iit certainly is astonishing and hard to comprehend that two of the most influential documents in all of world history (competing with the likes of the
Bible and
Luther's 95 Theses - I'd probably rank them above the
Quran, too) were created there, in that
humble little structure. And also so many freaking intelligent, famous men sat in that small man room at one time, for an entire summer! Afterwords, we feminishly scuffled along the sidewalk, freaking freezing, down to South Philly for some
stellar, classic Philly cheese steaks at
Jim's Steaks. After eating I checked out
South Street for a while, then we headed back to our hotel. I won't bore you with uninteresting details of the rest of the night. Somebody got slightly drunk on vodka.....Again...idiots....I ran into two kids from another team who were reading their Bible together, which I thought was pretty cool, so I talked to them for a while. We also practiced a little that night for our
We The People competition. That night, I had to sleep with a kid from the other political science class, whom I never really knew....that was weird.....
The next day, I'll just skip ahead to the competition. We arrived at the federal building, got to meet Judge/
First Lady Rendell. That was cool, even though I think her husband's
slot-machine idea is about the worst economic and social idea one could ever concoct.....We then headed off for our rooms. I'll exlain a little about the competition. It's entirely focused around our country's constitution, it's history, it's revisions, it's implecations and consequences and results. There are six units. Each unit has three questions. Each question requires a 4-minute presentation, prepared beforehand (for weeks/months/in some cases more than a year), which is presented to the judges. After the 4-minute presentation, there is then a six minute period in which the judges drill the presentators with questions that test one's analytical and evaluating skills, as well as knowledge (such as seeing what historical court cases, as well as present situations, the students can incorporate into their answers). For each unit, only one question is actually presented, but the team must be ready to present all 3 questions for each unit, because they do not know which of the three questions they're going to be asked until just before they present. Our teacher combined his two political science classes into one team, and split us up into six groups: one for each unit, with 5-6 people for each unit. My unit, unit 4 focused around the 14th Amendment. You must realize....this competition was TOUGH. Very prestigious. For example, here are the three questions we had to answer (4 minute presentation, 6 minute impromptu Q&A) (Question #2 was definitely the hardest):
Unit Four: How Have the Protections of the Bill of Rights Been Developed and Expanded?
1. "Nor shall any state...deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws." That clause in the Fourteenth Amendment marks the first use in the Constitution of the word "equal" regarding the rights of individuals. How would you describe what "equal protection of the laws" means? Does equal protection require treating all persons the same? If not, under what circumstances might persons be treated differently? Does equal protection require that everyone have equal opportunity?
2. "Justice Felix Frankfurter once explained that "due process...is not a technical conception with a fixed content." It embodies "that feeling of just treatment which has evolved through centuries of Anglo-American constitutional history." It represents "a profound attitude of fairness between men and men and more particularly between the individual and government." How have landmark documents such as Magna Carta, the Massachusetts Body of Liberties, the Declaration of Independence, and the 14th Amendment helped to develop the concept of due process? How and why does due process require government to show "fairness" in dealing with individuals?
3. American political writer Theodore H. White observed that "heroes and philosophers, brave men and vile, have since Rome and Athens tried to make this peculiar manner of transfer of power [elections] work effectively; no people has succeeded at iit better than the Americans." Do you agree or disagree with this statement? Why? What evidence of success would you point to? What evidence of failure can you offer? How can those shortcomings be remedied?
In both the 4-minute presentation, as well as the 6-minute responses, we had to cite numerous court cases, Federalist papers, philosophers, and contemporary examples - all to support your response to questions. So yea, all that to say that this competition was very prestigious and difficult. I learned
a lot through it. I remember first looking at some of the questions, and being ready to crap my pants, I had no idea how I'd spend 10 minutes talking about one of these questions!
So....the results: This was the state competition, which we qualified for. The first place team gets to go to D.C. and compete against the other states, each who have one representative team. The nationals is MUCH MORE prestigious, even than this. There, you get put up in a VERY expensive hotel for a week, and get to meet all sorts of important people, maybe even the president.
Well.................we took second place by 2 points.....OUT OF 1200! Out of 1200 points, we were 2 points behind first place! Can you believe that!? And the team that took first place? It was an AP Government class who's been preparing for the past year and a half.
Our team was simply two poli-sci classes combined (who did their work seperately - not together) that prepared for 6 weeks! And the past month and a half, we haven't even practiced, because we got new classes the second semester, being in block scheduling!
So just imagine: there's a total of an entire hour of each team presenting, citing all sorts of court cases, amendments, Federalist papers, contemporary situations, quotes, etc.....with all sorts of analyzation, evaluation, and free responses. So think about how minute (as in small - not 60 seconds) 2 points out of 1200 are! There's SO many places in our hour-long presentation, which, if you would've just tweaked or changed one MINOR thing, we could've won.
All in all though, I was happy. I learned multitudes. I also really wasn't too confident in my entire team...There's a lot of kids who are 1)only goof-offs and nothing more, and 2) frankly, not that intelligent. NONE of us expected to do so well. We all were fairly cynical and pessimistic going into the competition. But I must say, I left that room (before I knew the results), and I was
very impressed. We did a
stellar job! HECK YES! I really think any person would be totally blown away to see any of these teams present, really.
Apparently, a lot of judges wanted us to win, but not enough. Speaking of judges though, I had a very ironic encounter with one! First, I'll preface my story by saying that the judges for the competition were mostly circuit judges, lawyers, political science professors, and other law-related professionals. Well, during lunch, I just happened to meet the circuit judge presiding over the
Dover School District case! It was pretty cool/interesting to talk to him. I asked him a few questions about the case, his opinion, etc. It was funny to hear him talk about how devisive the two lawyers are. They don't like each other. Hehe. He said you can feel the tension when you're in a room with them. He was also commenting that, if the school loses the case - it'll hike up the taxes for everyone in the district. He said there are a lot of parents who favor intelligent design who want to testify, and he said he's not going to stop them, but iit's actually rather foolish for them to testify, because it probably won't affect the outcome, but iit'll simply prolong the case, and therefore hike taxes up even higher if the school loses the case. I also asked him my linngering question, (
expressed previously): I've read the
statement the school board has issued to teachers, and the statement that the teachers were supposed to read at the begining of the course. Nowhere does it
teach intelligent design. It simply says that Darwinism has some holes in it, and there are other theories which explain those holes, one being intelligent design, and there's a book available if any students are interested in reading more.
In fact, the teachers are specifically instructed not to teach intelligent design. Yet, contradictorily, the
ACLU is quoted as saying that Dover is the "only school in the nation that requires the teaching of ID". I told the judge I'm confused by the discrepency, and he said that basically, that's what the case boils down to, if you weed everything else out. The ACLU says that "teaching" includes the
mentioning of a subject (Ok, logically, that just doesn't make sense. If I mention Naazism during a WWII unit, would I
really be
teaching it or teaching about iit? Boy! I hope not! Maybe we can't talk about anything that the church has been involved in throughout history....or Islam....or fasccism, oh and we certainly can't mention about slavery before the Civil War, or racissm through the 1960's, because then we'd be teaching it! In fact, I guess we can't teach about the Scopes-Monkey trial either, because that includes mentioning creationism!), whereas the Dover school and
Richard Thompson, it's lawyer, says that, NO, "teaching" is...well...teaching. As in saying, "this is truth." So yea, the judge was a pretty cool guy. He found humor in the whole situation.
Came home then, and I was exhausted. But I didn't want to miss snow tubing with the youth group! So I went to that, which was really fun. Unfortunately though, I found out that Jess didn't make it onto the Peru team.....all the campaigning I did to try and convince her to go, as well as the leaders to let her go! All in vain! Oh well....I really I wanted her to go, but we must trust that God's will is different, but also perfect in His sovereignty and in His blessings....
All in all, it was a good two days...even if most of it was spent with some people who really hit the wrong buttons in me....Oh well....God grants me joy and patience....