I'd like to know people's thoughts on this article *cough cough Amanda*:
De-westernizing the Gospel
I can't fully agree with the man (after all, he's PCUSA! haha. Sorry, I couldn't resist). He makes some terrible statements ("[Contemporarization] is clothing the Good News in the cultural context of the younger generations"). But he made some interesting points. Such as:
The Good News became a threat when it was realized that Jesus had come both to challenge and to fulfill every culture in the world.
and
Those branches — spiritual, intellectual, physical, economic, social and bold witness of their new life — indicate what they feel are the six areas of their true humanity which need healing.
I'm somewhat intrigued, because I don't think I fully agree with the article (I'm not sure yet), but I certainly agree with those statements. I don't understand though, because they could easily be used, in fact, to counter his argument! Right? They seem to contradict the rest of his thesis. Maybe I'm just misunderstanding...
I want to hear people's thoughts on his idea. I disagree with him for the most part and I can't stand the contemporarization of the worship service (or at least the degree of it) as I see the horrible effects of it on today's modern church. But what do you do about actual different cultures? Not just making the service more contemporary to attract youth, but what do you do about cultures such as African and Eastern? Do you westernize new Christians from India or natives from Zimbabwe or converted Muslims from Indonesia? I believe worship services do have absolutes, and are not just open to cultural relevancy (I haven't decided to what degree, though). But what do you do about these cultures that have no similarities with a western culture? Particularly anyone Reformed, I'd like to hear your thoughts on the subject.
Strengthening however my view that PCUSA is a load of crap, is this article:
De-Triumphalizing the Gospel
This guy is a pastor at a church? I'm surprised he's not a Universalist! He completely misunderstands the definition of salvation, and misinterprets what the covenant actually was. And with his view on salvation, what the heck does "responsible witness to Jews" mean, anyway?
I think the only two statements I am in concurrence with is:
We have a tragic 1,900-year history of persecution, oppression, exclusion, barbarism, forced conversion, and kiilling and maiiming to answer for, to repent for, to make amends for and to accept responsibility forand
messianism has always been and continues to be central to Jewish self-understanding as well as to Christian.*I don't think this little excerpt even appears to be AT ALL - but if this appears to be anti-Semetic WHATSOEVER, that is not my intention. Trust me, I view Jews no different than I do any other human being on this planet, myself included.
This next article is extremely interesting, knowing the certain political side which PCUSA commonly takes, and some of the things it condones. I'm surprised to read someone from PCUSA supporting absolute morality. And the comment about government and foreign policy really surprised me.
What the New Year Holds
I'd agree with everything he says, except the image of Christ...I think the image of Christ does need to be toughened up. He wasn't a wuss. He's depicted in the OT as a blloody warrior who has just come back from battle. He's right that Christ turned the other cheek, and so that is how we need to be as well. That's exactly what we're called to do. But God is a just God. Justice is different from revenge, and someday there will be justice! Otherwise you'd have to cut out half of the Bible. He's right about evangelism, too. But we need to differentiate evangelism from Christ, and his just wrath, too.
Let me wrap up by saying, this is my favorite quote of the day:
Jesus...cannot be bulked up by the sinister, calculating minds that vomited out the “Left Behind” novels. Nor does he need a makeover by misguided idiots who exploit him for economic gain, market him to the masses, or “make” him relevantWow. He hit that one on the head! He dissed Left Behind, nailed Christianity exploiters, and rebuked relevancy makers!
Oh yea, the comment about the lady looking for Armaggedon was hilarious, too.
2 comentarios:
Hey man, let's talk some about this article [de-westernizing]. What else did you not like about it?
I think some consideration in regard to evangelism and cultural practice/identity is of the first order. Esp. the latter.
What i mean is that Christianity, while historically western, is also transcendent of western culture in history, and we are on the brink of a 'post-western' World, i.e. Globalism and postmodernity.
In the early Church, fellowship was distinctly Jewish and to jews, but as the disaspora spread the apostles to the corners of the World, the gentile population became the dominant ethnic/cultural identity. and the Jews began to think "what the heck do we do with these gentiles? they are different, but they are claiming Christ too." it became the first major internal-crisis in the church. do jews force jewish culture on gentile believers? should the greeks get circumcized? what?
it presented some interesting problems. but so to did greek culture in the church, i.e. platonism, duality, and the gnostics, which kept the early father busy fighting off syncrotism and heresy leading up to Nicea I and beyond.
But one thing that stood out in this article was this guy's excuse for cultural sensitivity because "of what we have done" to jews in the past as a result of our "enlightment" ideals. that's Crap with a capital 'c'.
bounce some ideas/critiques, bro.
Cave
Cave,
I see your point about the Jews trying to figure out how to deal with the Gentiles and not shove the Jewish culture upon them. And I also see your point about the problems Gentile cultures caused in the church. That's exactly the catch-22 I'm in right now, trying to figure out what exactly is right.
In respect to western culture, I certainly don't think that the culture itself is right, and that all other cultures are wrong. No. In fact I LOVE other cultures and embrace them. But I also realize that our western culture has been largely SHAPED by Biblical instruction. It's basically a product of the New Testament. Well, ok, it isn't always. But what I mean is that our western church has been wrestling for centuries trying to figure what is correct in a church-setting. If you started a Muslim, Hindu, or Jewish church that kept iit's cultural aspects IN the church setting and its procedures, isn't there a likely possibility of corruption (i.e. some sort of idol or any incorporation of their old religion that might penetrate and subsequently plague the new church). Just like the Jews had to realize that circumcision was not necessary to become a member of the church. In the New Testament I see Christianity more as being a throwing off of old cultural traditions (both for Jews and Gentiles), and then particularly after Constantine, Christianity was largely influential in the formation of what we know as western culture (of course there was pagan Greek and Roman influences however, too). Are you following my thought process?
I've also recently been learning about traditional liturgy and trying to figure out why exactly that's held in so high regard to a lot of people whose views I respect (that is, WESTERN liturgy...certainly not the Eastern Church's liturgy). And how does that fit into other cultures?
And I'm sure you'd agree with me on the attempts to contemporize the church...how that's reaped horrible effects on the church. Yet iit's an attempt to reach the youth who are, to a degree, a different culture than their parents' generation...
So I'm trying to figure out to what degree it is right to be culturally sensitive. I love different cultures, and I don't want to be a pretentious WASP! But in the globalized world we're approaching, I'm trying to figure out how the western Church should be dealing with converts from other cultures. Let me know more of your thoughts.
Publicar un comentario