sábado, abril 30

Some Food For Thought

Alright, so central Pennsylvania is pretty secluded from the outside world. It's pretty bias and lopsided, as Lancaster County is one of the most conservative counties in the country! To some degree or another, pretty much everyone takes Christianity as truth for granted, without even questioning it. And most everyone is pretty fundamentalist, at that. I don't often encounter too many skeptics and critics of Christianity (and I'm sure I won't at Houghton either! hehe), and being surrounded by so many fundamentalist, it's hard to weed out their erroneous ways from an unblemished biblical Christianity . So my friend sent this to me today, wondering what my response to it was. I'd like to put it out to everyone who reads my blog as well. I've got some responses of my own, but read these, and lemme know any thoughts or responses you have. I'd really like to make this post an active forum for discourse, so please, everyone leave your thoughts whether you think they're insightful or not:

You might be a Christian Fundamentalist if . . .

10 - You vigorously deny the existence of thousands of gods claimed by other religions, but feel outraged when someone denies the existence of yours.

9 - You feel insulted and "dehumanized" when scientists say that people evolved from other life forms, but you have no problem with the Biblical claim that we were created from dirt.


8 - You laugh at polytheists, but you have no problem believing in a Triune God.

7 - Your face turns purple when you hear of the "atrocities" attributed to Allah, but you don't even flinch when hearing about how God/Jehovah slaughtered all the babies of Egypt in "Exodus" and ordered
the elimination of entire ethnic groups in "Joshua" -- including women, children, and trees!

6 - You laugh at Hindu beliefs that deify humans, and Greek claims about gods sleeping with women, but you have no problem believing that the Holy Spirit impregnated Mary, who then gave birth to a man-god
who got killed, came back to life and then ascended into the sky.

5 - You are willing to spend your life looking for little loopholes in the scientifically established age of Earth (4.55 billion years), but you find nothing wrong with believing dates recorded by Bronze Age
tribesmen sitting in their tents and guessing that Earth is a couple of generations old.

4 - You believe that the entire population of this planet with the exception of those who share your beliefs -- though excluding those in all rival sects - will spend Eternity in an infinite Hell of Suffering. And yet consider your religion the most "tolerant" and
"loving."

3 - While modern science, history, geology, biology, and physics have failed to convince you otherwise, some idiot rolling around on the floor speaking in "tongues" may be all the evidence you need to "prove" Christianity. (Ryan's note: haha, ok, so that one isn't very hard to refute at all....:P)

2 - You define 0.01% as a "high success rate" when it comes to answered prayers. You consider that to be evidence that prayer works. And you think that the remaining 99.99% FAILURE was simply the will of God.

1 - You actually know a lot less than many atheists and agnostics do about the Bible, Christianity, and church history - but still call yourself a Christian.

You believe homosexuality is wrong b/c the bible says so? do you then think it's ok to possess slaves as written in Leviticus 25:44? do yo think fathers should be allowed to sell their daughters into slavery as stated in Exodus 21:7? Have you ever worked on the Sabbath, or had any friends or family who have? do you feel you or them should be punished by death as laid out in Exodus 35:2? do you like and have you ever eaten lobster or crabs? the bible states that eating shellfish is an abomination in Leviticus 11:10, the same exact words it uses to describe homosexuality. can you please explain why one is NOW considered an abomination, and the other is common place among christians? ...it's pretty convenient of you catholics and christians to pick and choose what you think you should believe in from the bible, just b/c you are prejuidice and scared

4 comentarios:

Anónimo dijo...

Ryan:

I think it may be best not to respond to mockery, especially not on a point-for-point basis. This list is one of the "You might be a husband/wife/redneck/sports buff...whatever...if you" constructions that we see all the time. There is usually some truth to these, or they would not be funny. We must have a sense of humor...don't "turn purple" over lists like these, but admit that that is sometimes how it looks, and some of these may even be true of some Christians, BUT....we do not claim to be, as a class, or individually, completely without sin. That is actually the point...we do sin, we are a collection of broken people with faults, some of which are unloving, and our only hope is that God will gradually change us by showing us our shortcomings.

Nevertheless, if your friend wants a serious response, I would say, first, you are not a Fundamentalist and don't want him to be one either. Insofar as any of these suggest a lack of concern for the lost, or happiness that some people will be punished, they are not how Jesus called us to be, who wept over the lost.

10: We do deny existence of other gods, but do not feel outraged. I feel no more outrage when someone says God doesn't exist than I do if someone says the world is flat. Other people's ignorance or error does not make me angry or hurt.

9. I do not feel insulted or dehumanized. Same idea as 10, error does not anger me. However, when the state insists on teaching the error to children as established fact, I may get angry at the state and fight against it. Not anger at error, but at insistence on teaching error, and the arrogance involved.

8. This takes some theological sophistication. The doctrine of the trinity is different in many ways from simply having 3 gods. This apparent inconsistency was clearly recognized by the earliest Christians, who were monotheistic Jews. If it is so inconsistent, why did they accept it? Fact is, it is still monotheism, it is simply a God who somehow merges within himself three aspects which, to us, are best described as "persons". To us, in which one person goes with one being, we do not have a suitable word to describe the kind of plurality of persons in one being that is the way God exists.

7. As in 1 and 2, our face does not turn purple because atrocities are committed in Allah's name. Nominal (ie, not true Christians) committed atrocities in Jesus' name (crusades and Inquisition). When antiabortionists killed doctors in Jesus' name, the church as a whole unequivocally condemned the action as murder. What has Islam said, as official Islam (ie, the Imams in Saudi Arabia, Iran, Egypt, Iraq...all the central, official lands of Islam) about 9/11? Islam still accepts atrocities, we do not. Concerning the slaughters in the OT, understanding this requires an understanding both of the ancient cultures involved, but more specifically the harder-to-understand idea that each life belongs entirely to God, and each life ends exactly when He says it will. We belong to Him because He made each individual one of us, but we do not belong to each other. Hence, we may not kill each other because we want to, but God may rightly (and actually does in every case, even if we die "naturally") specify when and how we are to die. He may "kill" us whenever he wishes, since "killing" us, from his perspective, is a) doing something he has every right to do as our creator and b) is simply changing our location from on-earth to in-heaven. From his perspective, there is no "end" to our existence, just a change in it.

6. Again, we do not laugh. In fact, we believe that many of these myths are hints about the truth. C. S. Lewis often said, "In Jesus, the great myths have become true." These myths hint at the intercourse (not sexual, but still intercourse) between beings material and beings spiritual. All religions have some aspect of the truth together with much error. We believe that the Bible and what it teaches about Jesus is true, completely, in what it actually means (ie, what God considers it to mean.) We may be, and have been, mistaken from time to time about what it actually says, for example, when we believed that it taught that the earth is at the center of the universe. In that error, we confused issues of "centrality" of earth and human beings in the story that relates us to God with physical, material centrality.

5. Your friend needs to distinguish uneducated Christianity from educated Christianity. Any group of many millions of everyday people will have primitive understandings mixed in with true understandings. I think this is another of the errors like the one above. Nothing in the Bible requires us to believe in a young earth. I believe in an earth several billion years old, and a universe older still. Your friend might be interested in knowing, however, that the best scientists believe that even 5 billion years is nowhere near enough time for life to have evolved on this planet without supernatural intervention. Hence, the famous Francis Crick (discovered DNA) believes in panspermia, that the genetic code was dropped here by space aliens.

4. This is the "narrow gate" criticism. Jesus said that "broad is the way that leads to destruction, but narrow the way that leads to life, and few that find it." This "exclusivity" comes not from our or God's desire, but is simply true in the nature of our everyday world. There are, from my house, about four different ways to get to the Davidsons, and billions of ways that do not lead to the Davidsons. There is one correct answer to the question, What is two plus two, but an infinite number of incorrect answers. It is the nature of truth, all truth, to be narrower than error, because Truth has to correspond to what actually is, and error doesn't have to correspond to anything at all. Hence, even if the contrariness of the heart of man didn't enter into the picture at all, we would expect there to be a lot fewer people who "get it right" than who get it wrong. There are simply a lot more wrong answers out there, to any question at all, than right ones.

When we come to questions of following God, of course, we have motivations that come into the picture as well. God requires submission to his rule; following him requires that we do not simply follow our hearts, but allow our hearts to be changed, and not by ourselves, but by someone else. This means that following the truth means denying one's own self and taking up the cross. This is not designed to be popular. One might expect, even if Jesus hadn't predicted it, that most self-centered humans would reject this way and follow one of the myriad of other ways that don't lead to life.

Our tolerance refers to our belief that we do not have the right to force anyone to believe, in fact, that we cannot force anyone to believe or follow Jesus. It does not believe that we think the other ways are true, because that is silly...there can't be two or more mutually exclusive right answers. But we don't force you to believe the right answer, we merely point you to it, and even perhaps pester you to reconsider, since the stakes on this questionn are so high.

About the aspect of eternal punishment, that is a much deeper topic that takes a lot of understanding about many aspects of time, persons, and reality to come to grips with. It should be noted that Jesus himself is saddened that anyone would go to hell, and it is written that God does not desire that any be lost and takes no joy in the death of the wicked. That He so respects our personhood that he allows us...is "tolerant" if you will...to insist upon our error, demonstrates the importance he places upon our choices and our responsibility.

3. This does not in any way prove Christianity. The idea is simply silly. Again, uneducated Christianity.

2. We do not think prayer has anything at all to do with "success rates". This is a magical view of prayer, that one might find among the pagans or the Wiccans. Prayer is conversation with God. Did we keep a running "success rate" number when we were little children and asked our physical father for things? When I asked for understanding, I would always get an answer, even if it was an answer grossly simplified so my young mind could grasp it. If I asked for candy, or to go to Disneyworld, or to have a horse, or to drive the car, or stay up till midnight, or get more privileges than my sister, the answer was, usually, "No." If I asked for money to go to college, I might get a mixed answer, in which I did get some, but not all, the money, so that I had to work myself. I understood that this was an answer that had my own good in mind, that my own father was not simply a money-tree or candy-store, but a person who interacted with me in such a way that my own growth would be supported. Our prayers to God are similar.

1. Uneducated Christians again. We should know more. Also, it is generally untrue that we know less. I am continually appalled at the ignorance of even "educated" non-Christians about the Bible that, if nothing else, is one of the books foundational to their own western civilization. Generally, the only atheists or agnostics who know "more" than Christians of the same age are antagonistic teachers in high school or university. The non-believing man=on-the-street knows a lot less, in my experience.

-----Original Message-----
From: Ryan Musser [mailto:umpa_lumpa_has_cootees@yahoo.com]
Sent: Saturday, April 30, 2005 6:17 PM
To: dkulp@hersheyfree.com; jkearns@leppc.net; wdavidson@psu.edu; davevm@paonline.com; amanda.smeltz@marquette.edu; hummer-3@juno.com; kelzbbee@yahoo.com; dwabt@geneva.edu; benjamin.zipf@ciuonline.com; lindsay.musser@houghton.edu; clear@hersheyfree.com; BMcCaveman@aol.com; cgroff@hersheyfree.com; jcdavis@cedarville.edu; Ehud79@aol.com; ghotihook0@hotmail.com; moore@covenant.edu; JAKEFERD@aol.com; charliefoxtrot61@hotmail.com
Subject: Tough Attacks


Ok, so living in central Pennsylvania, I don't come
across these questions too much. I very much more
experienced with handling someone who already has
basic belief in Christianity (whether they live it out
or not), or at the most extreme, I may deal with
someone who challenges Christianity as a whole, but is
rather uneducated and unsophisticated in their refutes
of Christianity (hehe). So just earlier today,
someone (a Christian very young in faith, but
nevertheless looking very promising!) sent this to me,
and asked me my thoughts on it. Thanks be to God, I
was able to give her a response that sufficed for her.
I've certainly got some of my own responses to these,
but I'd like to hear your thoughts upon these attacks, hopefully enabling me to benefit from any wisdom you have to impart! =) So feel free to respond, giving me any of your thoughts and reactions.

-Ryan Musser

Here it is:

You might be a Christian Fundamentalist if . . .

10 - You vigorously deny the existence of thousands of
gods claimed by other religions, but feel outraged
when someone denies the existence of yours.

9 - You feel insulted and "dehumanized" when
scientists say that people evolved from other life
forms, but you have no problem with the Biblical claim
that we were created from dirt.


8 - You laugh at polytheists, but you have no problem
believing in a Triune God.

7 - Your face turns purple when you hear of the
"atrocities" attributed to Allah, but you don't even
flinch when hearing about how God/Jehovah slaughtered
all the babies of Egypt in "Exodus" and ordered
the elimination of entire ethnic groups in "Joshua" -- including women, children, and trees!

6 - You laugh at Hindu beliefs that deify humans, and
Greek claims about gods sleeping with women, but you
have no problem believing that the Holy Spirit
impregnated Mary, who then gave birth to a man-god
who got killed, came back to life and then ascended
into the sky.

5 - You are willing to spend your life looking for
little loopholes in the scientifically established age
of Earth (4.55 billion years), but you find nothing
wrong with believing dates recorded by Bronze Age
tribesmen sitting in their tents and guessing that
Earth is a couple of generations old.

4 - You believe that the entire population of this
planet with the exception of those who share your
beliefs -- though excluding those in all rival sects -
will spend Eternity in an infinite Hell of Suffering.
And yet consider your religion the most "tolerant" and "loving."

3 - While modern science, history, geology, biology,
and physics have failed to convince you otherwise,
some idiot rolling around on the floor speaking in
"tongues" may be all the evidence you need to "prove" Christianity. (Ryan's note: haha, ok, so that one isn't very hard to refute at all....:P)

2 - You define 0.01% as a "high success rate" when it
comes to answered prayers. You consider that to be
evidence that prayer works. And you think that the
remaining 99.99% FAILURE was simply the will of God.

1 - You actually know a lot less than many atheists
and agnostics do about the Bible, Christianity, and
church history - but still call yourself a Christian.

Anónimo dijo...

Ok, here's my thoughts:

1) First of all, this is a satire piece: they are satirizing a group of
people, an activity that by nature involves exxaggeration, stereotyping
and caricaturizing. But the important part is that they have done us
the favor of specifying the group they are mocking as Christian
"fundamentalists." I forget the exact context around the formation of the
fundamentalists in the 20's, I remember it centered around separating one's
self from the world (and, many times, from reality.) You and I are NOT
fundamentalists--we are ORTHODOX, and that should be first in your
answer--these people are not talking about YOU. In fact, I have some of the
same problems with fundamentalists as this person does. Below, I've put
my responses to each critique.


Here it is:

You might be a Christian Fundamentalist if . . .

10 - You vigorously deny the existence of thousands of
gods claimed by other religions, but feel outraged
when someone denies the existence of yours.

*I don't feel outraged. In fact, I assume that that is what people will
do. My beliefs count denial of God's authority as basic to human
nature as is drinking water, and I find that true for myself as well. But
then, I'm not a fundamentalist.

9 - You feel insulted and "dehumanized" when
scientists say that people evolved from other life
forms, but you have no problem with the Biblical claim
that we were created from dirt.

*Projected feelings of "insulted" and "dehumanized" aside, the
important word here is "created." It's the BEING MADE in a divine image that
is special (that gives us a soul) not the material we were made from.
And, again, I am not a fundamentalist.


8 - You laugh at polytheists, but you have no problem
believing in a Triune God.

*See answer to above question #10. Also see Christian history. The
Trinity has been one of the most hotly debated and discussed elements of
the faith.

7 - Your face turns purple when you hear of the
"atrocities" attributed to Allah, but you don't even
flinch when hearing about how God/Jehovah slaughtered
all the babies of Egypt in "Exodus" and ordered
the elimination of entire ethnic groups in "Joshua" --
including women, children, and trees!

**Once again, not a fundamentalist. Christians have spent years and
years debating violence and war as mandated by God. Violent justice
carried out by a deity through human servants is actually one of the things
I understand MOST EASILYabout the Muslim faith...

6 - You laugh at Hindu beliefs that deify humans, and
Greek claims about gods sleeping with women, but you
have no problem believing that the Holy Spirit
impregnated Mary, who then gave birth to a man-god
who got killed, came back to life and then ascended
into the sky.

**Those of us who are not fundamentalists also read Paul, who
self-consciously called our beliefs a "folly." When dealing with the divine,
"bizarre" certainly does not translate to "untrue." That is why I DON'T,
actually, laugh at any of those things, because it's perfectly
plausible to have your gods interacting with the human race.

5 - You are willing to spend your life looking for
little loopholes in the scientifically established age
of Earth (4.55 billion years), but you find nothing
wrong with believing dates recorded by Bronze Age
tribesmen sitting in their tents and guessing that
Earth is a couple of generations old.

*I don't, actually, spend much time debating the age of the earth
because more and more I find that exactly HOW and WHEN the earth was created
has little effect on the whole of my faith. The second part of #5
refers to Scriptural inspiration, although I don't think the writer knows
this

4 - You believe that the entire population of this
planet with the exception of those who share your
beliefs -- though excluding those in all rival sects -
will spend Eternity in an infinite Hell of Suffering.
And yet consider your religion the most "tolerant" and
"loving."

* Actually I don't consider it the most tolerant and loving. I consider
it true, and I consider it to hold an astounding amout of grace--but my
God is 'not a tame lion.'

3 - While modern science, history, geology, biology,
and physics have failed to convince you otherwise,
some idiot rolling around on the floor speaking in
"tongues" may be all the evidence you need to "prove"
Christianity. (Ryan's note: haha, ok, so that one
isn't very hard to refute at all....:P)

* no need to respond to this one...

2 - You define 0.01% as a "high success rate" when it
comes to answered prayers. You consider that to be
evidence that prayer works. And you think that the
remaining 99.99% FAILURE was simply the will of God.

** Talking about prayer in terms of 'success' and 'failure' is really
missing the whole point of what prayer is.

1 - You actually know a lot less than many atheists
and agnostics do about the Bible, Christianity, and
church history - but still call yourself a Christian.


* once again, I am not a fundamentalist, and I humbly strive to avoid
this last accusation being true about me.

Anónimo dijo...

My word, the people posting on your site are some of my favorites EVER.

That being said:

I'd take issue with most of these "refutations" of Christianity as not actual arguments, but under-handed (and cowardly) attacks on the attitude and intellectual ignorance of Christians, which others have addressed perfectly. So I won't expand overmuch.

I will say that discussing the faith with someone who wants to undermine its credibility by making character attacks is usually something I just don't do. I'll talk with someone about God but only if they're genuinely interested, and not looking to just wipe my face in the dirt. That kind of person doesn't want to hear about Christ, they just want to be an antagonistic prick. And as such, it's easier for me to get on well with them (read: love them) if we don't breach the subject. I've had to have quite a bit of discernment here at Marquette as to whom I will engage when they offer comments about the faith or not. As Joe said, I refuse to answer to mockery. God doesn't need defended by huffy Christians. He can take care of Himself. This is a good place where I finally have learned to turn the other cheek, instead of "turning purple" as I might have a few years back.

Of course, some of those goofy character attacks they made do have their roots in truth. Remember, we aren't Christian Fundamentalists (even if you're at a church that is, bro, you're not. just so that you know.) Being a Reformed/orthodox Protestant makes us distinct from the larger body of evangelicals/fundamentalists. We're much closer in conduct and tradition to orthodox Anglicans and Catholics, even if there's some major doctrinal issues there. All of that to say, it's characteristic of a stereotypical Fundamentalist to not know systematic theology or doctrine in such a way that they are peaceful, due to its more profound matters. So they often settle on hot-topic issues like how old the earth is, or the pro-life train, or how Calvin is a shmuck, or whatever.

Regardless, here's some stuff that the little joke-list does reflect about fundamentalism, or things serious Christians ought notice:

-Fundamental Christianity often replaces mature faith (replete with doctrine and tradition, yes?) with emotional fury. "vigorously deny", "feel dehumanized", "face turns purple", etc. This is bad. Things like pantheistic religions and evolution really shouldn't bother us that much. Is it good to discuss them and even contest them? Sure. But why get so hot and bothered about it? God will reveal all things in due time.

- #7 isn't true. Most fundamentalists should flinch when they read Joshua. Because they probably aren't familiar or comfortable with a depiction of God who has destroyed other people the sake of his own.

- #4 is something I will address specifically, because this is important. First of all, our God is not "tolerant" in the way that word's meant here. Certain lifestyles and attitudes are not acceptable according to the Word, namely, any attitude or lifestyle that doesn't conform - out of submission - to God's holiness. Defiance is only tolerated by Him for so long, even from His own people, as should be patently obvious from the entire Bible. Yet God is merciful. He loves his creation enough that He even suffers the wicked to, oftentimes, enjoy a reasonably happy life on earth. Our religion is not "loving" as in, "God loves everyone and will ignore sin because of how much He loves them", but rather, "God loves His Son and His Son's bride with an unspeakably holy and powerful love... and will act accordingly." So, any Christian that thinks his God is loving and tolerant - in the aforementioned, current senses of the words - is wrong. It would be the Christian's goal to be honestly loving and patient with every human being. We ought love them for the image of God, which is Christ, weaved into their very fabric. That is enough reason to love anyone, regardless of their corruption. And finally, "religion" is an empty word. There is how God acts, how the Church acts, and how the world acts. That's all.

#1 is the real heart of the matter, and often true. So what? Remember, an individual can know everything they want about Christianity, can know a whole lot about God, and still have absolutely nothing to do with Him. Faith is a gift given by God, you will recall, and that is what makes someone a Christian. Read: trust in Christ for the salvation of our souls from our corrupted nature and daily deviance, and a radically changed heart and life as the result. Knowing about the Bible, Christianity, and church history is momentously important... but not salvific.

So yeah. The power of that list is zapped when we aren't concerned with the meanness of the attack. However, it's still good for us to be able to identify erroneous "fundamentalist" tendencies, as well as Reformed errors, Anglican errors, the errors of Christianity the whole way back. Yes?

Anónimo dijo...

Well, aside from the obvious sarcasm and fact-twisting, those points are painfully telling for the Church, esp. in Evangelical/Fundamentalist America: The criticisms of ignorance of the Bible and our own theology and history is quite perceptive; the ugly laughter, sneering and lovelessness towards others is too often true of us (cp. Derek Webb's "Tee Shirts") and the world sees that as Christianity - judgemental, harsh and hardly self-sacrificially Christlike; we've equated certain views of origins with 'truth' and often ostracize even fellow believers with different views of these things; we've done and taught apologetics so poorly that we often feel paralyzed when these criticisms are levelled at us.

Jesus did not go around 'outraged' at the kind of ignorance and hostility we read below (like the church so often does today), instead he died to save sinners while they were still at enmity towards Him, seeing them as sheep without a shepherd.

While I/we repent of these things individually and corporately we would do well to remember that if they hated Christ, they will hate us, too.