sábado, abril 9

They Critique Like a Woman

I must admit, this is one reason why I like Bush. He's not a pushover like Kerry was - or many other Democrats for that matter. Some things that stuck out to me in the article:

"I think the Democrats have to be clearer about offering alternatives, not just the critique," said Democratic pollster Celinda Lake. "People already know what the problems are, they want to know the solutions."


All I've heard are critiques for the Democrats. It's all the Kerry campaign was based on: critique of the war, critique of the economy, critique of homeland security. Problem is, it became evident that Kerry was critiquing and opposing, simply for the sake of critiquing and opposing. Kerry had had no alternatives. It didn't matter. For every issue, he simply stated Bush's stance, than pointed out the falacies and failures for every Bush approach. He would've won many more votes if he could've simply convinced the every day American that he had a remedy to the problems, a solution to the current mess - whatever the relevant issue may be. This philosophy continues into the Democrats in Congress. You got a problem with Bush's Social Security plan? Well then freaking prove to me what the heck you're gonna do to provide me at the age of 65 with the money that I'm going to be giving you all my adult, working life. I don't give jack about whether the projected bankruptcy for the system is actually X number of years after what the Bush administration is projecting. The liberals simply parade around, procrastinating as long as they can, fearful of their precious little ideology of big government being squandered. They're not the party for the people. That's a load of crack, a ploy they use to win votes. They've been entirely inconsistent in looking out for the good of the people. What I care about is the fact that in a few years, millions of workers are going to be leaving the workforce, demanding pay from Social Security, and there will not be nearly an equivalent amount of new workers replacing them, and thus sustaining the system. To make matters worse, the governments collection from income taxes is going to drop significantly, plummeting us even further into debt and closer to the impending consequences. Bush's plan may not be a revelation sent directly from the Divine Himself, but ya know what? At least he's got a freaking resolution, and he's taking action. If Kerry was in office and the Democrats controlled Congress, the common public would be blissfully naive of the impending doom, because Kerry and the Democrats of Congress are so much of pushovers that they'd pretend they didn't even know of the problem, being afraid to open the Pandora's Box. Bush isn't always right. But at least he is willing to stomp his foot on the ground, tighten the belt and roll up his sleeves. Even if those liberal pussies try to slap him around a little.....

"I think they're trying to ride the fence and that doesn't work," Johnston said. "Say what you believe and stick with it."


And that's what George W. Bush is doing. Wrong or right, he's willing to open a Pandora's Box and let the crap hit the fan - even if it splatters all over him. But at least he gets the mess out in front of the public eye so it can be dealt with. And then he picks his position and pushes for it, in hopes of getting something done.

2 comentarios:

Anónimo dijo...

Hm. Got a bone to pick here.

Kerry, I think, did have plans for resolving some issues that loom large for us now. I remember reading a very insightful article about him that showed that his background legislation and involvement dealt significantly with international crime. Now, that opened worlds of understanding to me: Kerry wanted to change the tack of how terrorism in the world is being combated. He wanted to treat terrorism like an international crime - like drug trafficking, etc. - as opposed to Bush's stance. How do you attack a crime? Well, you punish the criminal. But that assumes that the criminal has already committed the act. Bush is attacking pre-emptively, acting to eradicate centuries of dictatorships and turning areas upside-down to try to destroy the problem at what he perceives is its roots.

That's why I can't condemn Bush for what he's doing abroad. He's looking for a solution that's not a Band-Aid, he's looking to root out a problem at its socio-cultural roots. He's violently stripping away a lot of oppression with methods that aren't socially acceptable. Like war. And it's for a cause to which we don't see an easy end. And I just can't condemn his go-in-with-guns-blazing attitude... not when there are people gaining civil liberties, gaining a semblance of public and private life that isn't threatened by the shadow of nutcase dictators.

Anyway, Kerry really did have an idea about how he wanted to handle that "problem" of a so-called ineffective and unnecessary war. He just didn't talk about it. And that's in keeping with the old, OLD style of Democrats - namely, the belief that the people aren't capable of handling the complex and nuanced solutions that a Demo. candidate might have to offer. So Demos sometimes avoid talking about their plans, because they're afraid that they'll be misunderstood by the public, or, in Kerry's case, seen as too wimpy in the face of a President that people seemed to like for his big-britches demeanor.

So yeah: that might be why we don't hear so much talk of solutions.

And then, my thought that the Demo party won't survive another 20 years is for the exact opposite thought: they're just a loosely grouped-together band of dissidents. They don't have a unified solution because they don't have enough in common to come together, to unify. And I think that's what cost them the election - they don't really represent anything but critique. Matter of fact, they're so hard to identify as anything but pissy that "they" is probably an over-generalized word.

Thoughts?

Anónimo dijo...

Hm...interesting point. I've known the Democrats to avoid going into detail as well, in the name of meeting the people's level of understanding. Although most of the time I've been rather unimpressed, and more convinced of it being a cop-out more than anything else. But nevertheless, you make a good point that I didn't consider, and I certainly didn't come across his plans to fight terrorism. I've heard the crime approach, but I never was informed of the nuances, or even the general outlines of such an approach.

But I still think Kerry would've been better off facing up to Bush's "big britches demeanor" and using his exasperatingly skilled rhetoric and debating skills to push his plans, rather than being ambiguous in his approaches. At least people would've known that once he sat in his big leather chair in the Oval Office, he actually would've had plans to crack down and start initiating......

And I certainly agree with you on the fact that the Democratic Party only represents critique. And by no means am I against critique. How else can a democracy strive? But for the love of all things good and sacred, at least give us something worth thinking about when the critique is expressed!