martes, mayo 3

Editorial

I was reading the newspaper today. The letters to the editor always invoke a variety of emotions in me, as I'm sure they do for everybody: laughter, boredom, agreement, anger.

In this post, I'm going to focus on the last emotion. I have never responded to a letter before. I'm either too apathetic, realize that it won't sway the opinions of those who are so obstinate, or else I know that everyone else will respond to it.

One of tonight's letters though was enough for me. Particularly after all the thinking I've been doing after seeing Hotel Rwanda (which I plan on posting on soon). Here is the letter:

Why are we in Iraq? It's just another Vietnam where nobody wins.

Sadam's army was made up of the sons of the middle class - just like you and me. They didn't mind torturing and killing their own countrymen as long as they got paid for it. They (the radicals) still don't mind. This is their problem, not ours.

I seem to remember we fought a revolutionary war for our freedom and then we fought a civil war to take care of our internal differences.

We have now spent multi-billions of dollars over there when we need it here. Elderly people can barely afford to keep their homes because of taxes and expenses. Millions have no health insurance and no prospect of getting it - it's too expensive. Medicare and Social Security are in dire trouble and could go under. But we have billions of dollars to give to our enemies.

Personally, and quite frankly, I don't give a hang about the Iraqi government, their economy or their people, if they're too spineless to take care of their own problems.

We are the are the wealthiest, most powerful nation on the planet. With good learship, we could make up the dollars. But if "only" (and I put that in quotation marks) if "only" one American died there today, but it happend to be your child, husband, wife, or friend, it's one too many - now ain't it?

P.S. Yea, they have oil. But guess what? We have food an dwater. The last of all wars will be fought for food and water. And, by the way, we never got Osama or any weapons of mass destruction. I know I feel a lot safer, don't you?

"Personally, and quite frankly," her letter pissed me off. I'm sick of that attitude. Despite her horrible incoherency and my lack of understanding her rationale for the entire last two paragraphs, I decided to respond - mostly to the text which I highlighted in bold. The bold text is what angered me the most. Here's my letter which I emailed to the editor tonight:

In response the Roberta J. Long's letter (5/03 New Era):

Besides the fact that your attempted rationale was rather incoherent, I was appalled by your arrogance. As I read your letter I was reminded why, even as a high school student, I am so often disgusted by my fellow American citizens. It comes as no surprise to me that the rest of the world hates us when we manifest such audacious egocentricity.

Laying aside the politics of why we are in Iraq, you had the audacity to admit that "we are the wealthiest, most powerful nation on the planet" and yet simultaneously state your indifference to the prevalence of "torturing and killing" done by Iraqis, to Iraqis, during Sadam's reign. "This is their problem, not ours," you said. This is a direct insult to the principles of both myself as well as many other Americans: "To everyone who has been given much, much is required." Your indifference is as despicable and depraved as that of the actual torturing and killing which occurred in Iraq.

If you don't believe me, go to your local Blockbuster and rent the newly released "Hotel Rwanda". The aforementioned principle I stated is not even exclusively an American principle. It's a global principle. I'd like to see you state your argument to Paul Rusesabagina, a Hutu Rwandan who continually trusted in the Western forces to intervene and stop the Rwandan atrocities that killed one million people in 100 days. Why did he trust them? Because they were powerful, and therefore capable of preventing the one million deaths that occurred in 1994. Unfortunately, Paul's trust in the powerful (and supposedly compassionate) West was shattered when the West chose to ignore Rwanda because it was "their problem, not ours."

Your letter reminds me of a line in the movie. Speaking of the atrocities that were occurring in Rwanda, the reporter said that Western people would "see [the video footage] and say 'Oh my God. That's horrible.' And then go back to eating their dinner."

Is it really just their problem? Or being the most powerful and influential nation in the world, is it our responsibility, as well, that helpless, innocent victims are being massacred by the millions around the globe?

4 comentarios:

Anónimo dijo...

hey, yea that def pisses me off that that writer thinks we should just focus on our own country and stop helping others....we as a nation have a lot so i think its our responsibility to reach out....but that doesnt mean i'm for the iraq war or any other wars....im just saying i think thats a selfish & stupid reason for opposing the Iraq war or wars in general
& i have to see that movie!

~SB

Anónimo dijo...

SB,

Well, all politics aside for ULTERIOR motivations for entering a war, I think that if you want to help innocent victims, war and violence is inevitable. Could we have diplomatically dealt with Hitler? I highly doubt it! He wanted to take of the world. He didn't give crap about anything else.

Same with Hotel Rwanda. After you watch the movie, I'd love to talk with you afterwords. You have to be very wise about making decisions about this, but realize that sometimes violence does help!

Look at it on smaller scale. If you were in a dark alley in the city, and someone jumped you and was in the process of assaulting you, who would you want to save you? Some timid wuss who comes up to the mugger or rapist and says, "Hey man. How about you stop assaulting her. Come over to my house, we'll have some tea, and we can talk about a deal we can work so that you'll stop raping her."

You want that guy to try and save you? Or do you want a 250-pound ripped guy who's going to come running to your help, jump on top of this guy, and beat the living pulp out of him in order to 1) save you, and 2) make sure this jerk-off learns his lesson and never touches a girl again without her permission?

I don't know about you, but the latter choice sounds much more appealing. Not only does it immediately save YOU (with the first scenario, the rapist would laugh in the guy's face, and probably put him at gunpoint, too!), but the second scenario also makes sure that this creep has learned his lesson by having the tar beat out of him. In the first scenario, not onlhy would the rapist laugh in the guy's face, but he'd also never learn his lesson. In fact, he'd have even more incentive to continue raping girls if everytime he'd do it, someone would be there offering him gifts in order to make him stop!

Look at little kids. Which ones are the ones that are behaved well? The ones who are disciplined after doing something wrong, or the ones who are bribed and given candy everytime they do something wrong? It's the kid who gets disciplined that behaves the best, because the other kid knows that everytime he does something bad, he gets candy out of it!

Now let's put these two scenarios on a larger scale with countries: Instead of putting yourself in the shoes of a girl being raped, put yourself in the shoes of a minority in a country who is being politically oppressed - even tortured and killed - by a dictator, or by the majority. Do you want a country to save you who's going to sit down and have tea with the perverted, inhumane murder in order to try and stop him? Or do you want a country who's going to act boldly, courageously, and manly by actively invading the country and kicking the crap out of that pervert and saying to him, "We've have enough of your freaking bullcrap, and we're sick of it!", and they down their fist and says, "NO MORE OF THIS CRAP!". I don't know......If I was a Jew in the middle of the Holocaust, I certainly would want the latter.

Now take the little kid scenario again. Which behavior is going to result in rulers who are more behaved? 1) Everytime there is brutality, massacres, and genocides commited, the responsible party is punished or 2)the responsible party is bribed and rewarded everytime they do something wrong, and therefore they cunningly realize that nobody is going to punish them, and in fact, they'll be rewarded everytime they misbehave?

We need to be wise in how we use our power. We shouldn't be war-hawks. And we should also use our power for other ways of helping. For example, a group from my church recently went over to Thailand to help with tsunami relief. This is what the people said to them: "People from all over the world come here to vacation, including Americans. When tragedy happens, everyone else leaves and doesn't come back to help....except Americans. They're the only ones who come back and help."

Now that is awesome. That makes me proud. That's how our reputation should be. But we don't want a reputation like those pussies in Europe who will do ANYTHING and EVERYTHING to avoid fighting. We should also have the reputation that, when there is crap going on in the world, we stand right up to it, and say, "This is freaking enough! We will tolerate this NO MORE!", and then back up our words with action (unlike Europe.) That is just as compassionate and helpful as going to Thailand and helping rebuild houses after the tsunami!

Anónimo dijo...

hey ryan...you make good points...tho i disagree w/some lol..and still have to see the movie

i definately agree that the acts of goodwill by americans are what makes me proud to be in this country and world
but w/the "if i was getting raped" situation. sure id want someone to come and get the dude off of me, definately, but i wouldnt want them to kill him...or hurt him unnecesarily...i don't think that would truly teach him a lesson...i dont believe someone can learn something, or feel something change INSIDE of them by having a fist punched in their face...

my mom has always said that if someone was to come into our house and try to kill me, shed do everything in her power to stop them(including violence) but not kill them. and i respect her for that. i dont want anyone to kill for me.
also w/the discipline idea...there are many studies that show that positive reinforcement works better than punishment...not like giving someone a reward for doing bad...but when they do good acts....and of course there needs to be punishment in certain cases...but violence begets violence...even if there are good intentions behind the acts of violence, when someones family has been killed by a stray bomb, a "casualty" of war..they arent going to see those good intentions

and w/hitler...i have no good answers w/that situation...all i know is we need to be preventing these deperate situations from arising...before a person like hitler can take control..
we need to be giving more aid to other countries in need...b/c even though we(the us) give a lot, we dont give nearly as much proportionally to what we have... by keeping lots of money & by having sweat shops and by attacking other countries...its all contributing to terrorism...

and i think we should also form "think tanks" to research peaceful alternatives to global situations...if we put as much money in to that as we do in the military imagine what could be done. ghandi did it...in south africa too...im not saying all war will go away. but i think we owe it to the future generations to at least try...it cant hurt to try right?

Anónimo dijo...

Great post, Ryan. Good letter. Hope it gets published.