This is the is Islam that we deal with. Even right here in the heart of America:
"The mushroom cloud is on the way!" they yell in Arabic in the middle of NEW YORK CITY!
There is no peaceful Islam. Anyone who says so has not truthfully read the Qu'ran or the Hadiths, nor studied Muhammad's life.
And this quote?
“The Jews and Christians will never be pleased with you until you follow their religion [or ideology].”Now come on. That's funny.
Ah, the irony!
12 comentarios:
Hmmm, worth pointing out that Christianity was also spread through much of the world by conquest and forced conversion. Islam invaded what, northern Africa and a bit of Europe and India? Hah! Amateurs. Christians pretty much genocided an entire hemisphere.
True, but my point is Islam in its very canonical foundations is violent. Christianity is not. Yes, there is the Old Testament, but it is precisely that - the old testament. It was for a group of people in which the religion WAS the state. A state can never be pacifist, or else it will eventually cease to exist. Christianity, however, has no biblical basis of being a state religion. People have tried to make it one. But the very roots of Christianity are that of a minority group of people located within a state which does not support the religion. Thus, it was impossible for Christianity to spread through conquest until it became a state religion. Constantine really through a mix into things, and Christians spent hundreds of years struggling with the idea of state vs. church. Just read medieval Christian political philosophy: Giles of Rome, John of Paris, Dante, Marsilius of Padua. They all are trying to figure out whether the Church should be separated from the state, and if so, who should be the most powerful.
At least they struggled with it though. Islam is much like the Jewish nation. There is NO distinction between church and state in Islam. Christianity - despite many times where the Church WAS the state - is still unique in its historical claim of always having a sense of separation between Church and state. That concept is completely foreign in Islam. Which is why I'm really begining to think that democracy is a bad idea in the Middle East (e.g. Hamas and Afganistan).
Whereas the Bible progresses from violence in the Old Testament to the idea of pacifistic evangelization in the New Testament, Islam is actually just the opposite. Muhammad's jihads actually progressivily increased as he aged. Islam became more violent as revelation continued. The Bible is the exact opposite. As divine revelation progressed on the continuum from the Mosaic/Torah Judaism to exiled Judaism into Christianity, it actually becomes more peaceful. And whereas the Jewish nation conquered mainly for political reasons (not necessarily to evangelize), the core of Islam belief is to Islamize the entire world through conquering.
I condemn the Christian conquest and forced conversion as much as you do. It is not biblical. But Muslims can not make the claim that violent Islam is not Qu'ranical. Just the opposite. And actually, the Middle East to India alone is about the territorial size of Europe. Then add the Muslim conquests of Northern Africa, Spain, and the Bulkans, and you've got yourself more conquest and forced conversion than those wretched Christians.
And as I finish writing this response, I looked at your LiveJournal....is this Dan Perrine?
*Balkans
Yep, it's me.
No, sorry, you can't write off the Old Testament that easily. I know it's a popular thing to do in Christian circles, but those less-inclined to be sympathetic will insist that, if you're going to pick out violent passages from the Koran, you've got to account for the violent ones in Christianity.
Also worth noting is that the militant expansion of the Islamic Empire was not just about evangelism; the areas that they conquered were significantly inferior culturally (including Dark Age Europe). It was about expanding civilization, with religion as part of the package. Not an excuse, mind you, but it's very much equivalent to what Europe did with Christianity once it gained enough power and organization to do so.
With just about any religion, you'll (at least in the modern era) have a vast majority of clergy and followers who hold it to be a religion of peace, and a few whackjobs who want to kill everyone who doesn't pray to their version of God. This goes as much for Christianity in America as it does for Muslims in the Middle East. Trying to judge the character of a faith based off the beliefs of a few extremists and forebears with radically different views and values just ends up making everyone look bad.
I'll concede on your point of post-Muhammad expansion being civilizational and not exclusively religous.
The problem I see, however, in respect to the religions' claims on divine inspiration. There IS a difference between the violence in the OT and Qur'an. If the Qur'an was constructed so that later revelation denounced violence, or vice versa, if the NT never denounced the use of violence - then I would have no foundation of an argument. But there is a basic difference between the two religions in the sense that the Qur'an condones MORE violence as revelation continues. Mohammad becomes MORE violent as his life progresses. Christianity annuls the use of violence as opposed to the Israelite conquest. And the only argument I can logically put forth is not that it is a contradiction, but a progression in revelation. As the Kingdom of God is established and revealed further, His people become more pacifistic in terms of conquest.
I understand that this is similar to the stereotypical naive, uneducated Conservative Christian argument, but I've actually only recently been persuaded by it. I used to lean towards the argument that there are off-the-wall, extreme Muslims just as there off-the-wall, extreme Christians. But since I've studied Islam, I've actually been persuaded otherwise. I've heard several very intelligent people who have studied Islam in-depth explain the recent rise of radical Islam as being the Islamic equivalent of both the Great Awakening and the Reformation. In otherwords, Islam had suffered for years with nominal Muslims as well as mislead Muslims. This new rise of radical Islam is going back to the Qur'anical and Muhammadian roots.
If there are Muslims out there that decry the current violence, claim Islam as a religion of peace, and want to dialogue with Christians, Jews, and the secular West - then hey, great! Let's work together and see what we can accomplish. But I'm not convinced that they represent orthodox Islam. They represent a new Islam that can't take the Qur'an for what it says.
I am leary of saying what I'm saying. I know it appears to be ignorant, naively over-simplified, and passionately motivated by religion. Like most conservative Christian arguments are. But I believe that actually it's ignorant and naive - and very dangerous - to write off radical Islam as just being "radical." Instead, as its own state and as part of the international community, we need to stop being idealistic and naive, accept that Islam is radical to its core, and figure out the best way to deal with that. Otherwise, we're in for a big surprise. Europe is discovering this more and more already.
And in my analysis, I'm seeking political implications - not religious. I'm not looking for a Christian crusade. I think it's important for the U.S., however, to realize the truths of Islam in order to defend its borders and its people. By that, I don't mean that every Muslim is violent and dangerous and shouldn't be allowed in the country. Every Muslim is not like that. But that's because they choose to be and they've adapted the Western reluctance to radical, violent religion - not because they represent true Islam.
I can't figure out how to state what I want to say next. My inclination is to say: "The U.S. needs to treat Islam just as they would any state that is an enemy." But I'm reluctant to say that, because that makes it sound like I'm skeptical of every Muslim - like every Muslim is a whacko. I'm not skeptical of every Muslim. There are plenty of peaceful Muslims. But Islam is not peaceful. I guess what I want to say is that the U.S. needs to be leary of orthodox Islamic doctrine, because it has the potential of creating enemies of the state and threatening the well-being of the American people. Muslims are not inherently dangerous. But the Qur'an is.
Oh, and I re-read my original response, and realized I made several funny spelling mistakes. My excuse is that it was 1:30 in the morning.
Interesting reading, its good to see you've started posting again.
I can't debate Christian theology versus Islamic theology since I lack knowledge of either.
Its interesting to compare the violence of Christians and Muslims. Christians, or people calling themselves 'Christians' anyway have committed horrible crimes and started many wars. Crusades, colonization and settlement of the Americas, colonization and (limited) settlement of Africa, etc. A lot of this was done for political and financial reasons. They tried to justify it as doing it to spread the Gospel, etc, etc. But it was just an excuse - did Cortez and the conquistadores really care about spreading the message of Christ? I think not - they were just in it for the gold. Islam has been constantly expanding as well - but the spreading of their religion seemed to be one of the main goals of their expansions. Not just an excuse for expansion, but a legitimate and justifiable (to them) reason for it.
Culture can not be ignored. Until quite recently in world history, Christians were still using their religion as an exuse to practice imperialism. The colonial system has really only disappeared over the last 50-100 years. And over the past 50 years, society has become increasingly more and more secular. Perhaps this increased secularization has led to the decreased militarism.
Islam has been increasinly militant over the past 50 years. Hmm. I think it might be a direct result of Western Imperialism. After the Ottoman Empire fell, Europe carved up the Middle East. They took the Muslims land, so the Muslims increasingly turned to religon. We've left now, but our culture still affects theres as our corporations sell them more and more and more goods - increasing resentment, increasing nationalism, increasing Islamism.
Ok, I'm tired (worked 21:30 to 06:30) - if I think of anything else, I'll post it later.
Ok, I see where you're going here. I'm still going to have to object to classifying the faith as an inherently violent one though. Like you pointed out, Islam is currently going through a revival. Using Christianity's own history as an example, during revivals adherents often turn to the more conservative, extreme expressions of their faith. Moreover, consider the political situation of much of the Islamic world right now. Many Muslims live in a situation where they're oppressed by bloated monarchies, in turn propped up by Western oil interests. In such a situation, it really isn't a surprise that people tend to focus on the parts of Islamic scripture that speak to their anger and frustration. Were it not for this political situation, I highly doubt you'd see the violent expressions of Islam that we are now.
Violence is certainly an aspect of Islam, as much as it is of Christianity. It's not the only aspect though, and we can't write off the faith of over a billion people as inherently violent when their political and social situation is as it is.
Todd,
Thanks for responding. First, I would agree that many things that were done in the name of Christianity simply used Christianity as a means for reaching their actual goals, such as many of the conquistadores. But not always. That's too easy of a way out, I think. I think other times, Christians were simply confused, such as the Crusades. I think one of the worst mistakes made in Christianity was the establishment of a Christian state. That really confused a lot of Christians for years. Christianity wasn't made to run a state. Old Testamen Judaism was. But not Christianity. It's earliest foundations come from being a persecuted religion in an intolerant Roman Empire. When Constantine got the great idea to make it the official religion (and who knows whether that was sincere or out of personal ambition), that really screwed things up. For more than a millennia - even still - Christians struggle with how Christianity is to interact with the temporal/state rule. Should it be one and the same? Should it above the state? Below the state? Should they be separated?
I think when it becomes one with the state, sincere motives get mislead and can very easily do damage. Even now, I struggle with some domestic issues. Like gay marriage...as a Christian who is views as unequivocally wrong - what side do I take? Well, I think I've finally decided to come down with the conservative Christians, but perhaps for different reasons. I think the state should ban gay marriage, because I sincerely believe that it will have harmful effects on society as a whole. Marriage is very useful to the state for keeping society intact and manageable. My religious views having nothing do with it.
Anyway, that was a tangent. Shady characters like the conquistadores probably just utilized the spreading of the Gospel for their own interests. But other times, many people sincerely, but mislead, believed that forceful conversion was an acceptable thing to do. St. Augustine (who over his life, actually swayed back and forth over the issue) put forth a very interesting argument that compared forced conversion to the forced discipline an adult puts upon the child. Even if the original forced conversions are atrocious, and the response is due to coersion and not sincerity - eventually, a generation or two later, an entire society WILL be sincere Christians. And that precisely has happened often throughout history. It happened in Europe, South America, Africa, etc. And although that still may sound like a sketchy argument, put yourself in the shoes of someone who wholeheartedly believes that the gospel saves people from hell! They really, truly are convinced that they are doing the best possible thing for these people. When I first read Augustine's argument, it really made me sincerely consider if forced conversion was legitimate. His argument, I honestly think, is a good one, is legitimate, and I would concede to it. Except for one thing. Even what he argues is true and you're saving generation upon generation of people by brutally treating just one generation, you still have to take into account what the Author of your faith commands. And if He doesn't command conversion through coercion, then you best not be doing it. Even if it is successful.
What makes a situation like the Inquisition, or the Crusades for that matter, interesting is the fact that Christianity was not united in support. Vitoria is an example of a Christian in the time of the Spanish Inquisition who questioned the legitimacy of the whole process. And there were people during the Crusades too.
Now, I understand that, the whole reason we are having this debate is because today there are also Muslims who are questioning the legitimacy of the whole process of the jihad. However, the reason I see a contrast between Christianity and Islam is because, if I took the Muhammad to be a divine prophet, and the Qur'an and Hadiths to be divinely inspired, then I would be signing up to be a camper at Osama's Summer Terrorist Training Camp. In other words, I support the terrorists in the fact that I believe the Qur'an DOES call for violence, coersion, and conquering in the name of Allah (but I don't believe the Qur'an is divinely inspired, obviously) (side note: the fact that in Islam there is no separation between state and religion supports the view of conquer and convert). I do not, however, see the Bible supporting forced conversion and militarily conquering in the name of Christianity. This is why I can say that the people who renounced the Crusades and the Inquisition represent true Christianity and simultaneously say that the Muslims who renounce the fundamentalist view of jihad do not represent true Islam.
For colonization, I would argue that, yes, earlier colonization was done in the name religion, but I would say that during a large portion of the latter part of the modern era, secular states colonized for not other reason than economics.
I would say, however, that the rise of Islamic imperialism goes back much further than recent Western imperialism. Ever since the decline of the Ottoman Empire when it was turned from Vienna's gates September 11, 1683 (note the date!), Islam has been harboring feelings of retaliation and revenge. The fall of the Ottoman Empire provoked it even more. And then Western domination was the last straw. I think the cultural imperialism has both been a cause of Islamic militarism, but also an excuse. Islamic resentment existed long before that. Heck, it even goes back further than 1683. 732 the Muslims were defeated in France, keeping them from expanding and eveloping all of Europe, and thus would've resulted in a completely revamped world history. We'd all be Muslim right now. Resentment goes back to the Crusades into the Holy Lands. Yes, Christians provoked that, but Muslims provoked the Christian provocation. The Muslims conquered what was traditionally Christian lands. Now, I guess the problem is, it goes back to eventually time when Constantine made the Roman Empire Christian, thus creating "Christian lands."
So, all that tangent to say, I think Muslim resentment and militarism is not new. It's been harboring for centuries, recent globalization has resulted in more access to power and technology, resulting in more militarism. The rise of Islamic fundamentalism is not a new form of Islam. As I mentioned above, this rise is much more similar to something like the Great Awakening in Christian America and Europe. Interestingly, the Great Awakening happend, most likely, as a result of industrialization. People moved into towns, adapted anonymous lifestyles (as opposed to the accountability present when living in a small town), and therefore morals and ethics dropped significantly. It's been convincingly argued that the Great Awakening is essentially what saved America from down-spiraling into chaos and anarchy as morals are destroyed. The Great Awakening, and the rise of the importance of religion, prevented this from happening. Interesting enough, Islamic fundamentalism has risen shortly after these backward Islamic societies began industrializing into modern societies.
So, all that to say, I'm convinced that Islam is inherently militant and violent, despite the rather recent objection by moderate Muslims, and Christian, despite its pathetic and embarrassing history, is foundationally peaceful.
Dan,
I guess I just see trouble in the future if we subscribe to some sort of...I don't know...political correctness by writing off Islamic fundamentalism as just fundamentalism and not being more skeptical about the Islamic faith as a whole. Skeptical, not as Christians, but skeptical as politicians and supporters of those politicians.
On the micro-level, in Christian-Muslim interaction, I'd love to see more dialogue and engagement; Christians seeing Muslims as humans, not as barbarous killing and hating machines. But more human-to-human interaction with the barriers broken down.
I guess it may sound kind of backwords from reality. And I'm not sure how to reconcile the macro/political view with the micro/relational view.
I guess I've just got a problem policially with a religion that scripturally divides the world into two categories: dar al-islam, "The house of submission," and dar al-harb, "The house of war."
Particulary when my country is still considered party of the "house of war."
Publicar un comentario