Not long ago, an ex-con named Umar Abdul-Jalil gave a speech in which he said the "greatest terrorists in the world occupy the White House," and that the "Zionists of the media" should not be dictating "what Islam is to us."
That was bad enough, but what was worse was the fact that Jalil is the chief Islamic chaplain in the New York City Department of Corrections.
After his comments became public, he was suspended from his job. But New York's Mayor Bloomberg refused to dismiss him, claiming that his right to free speech covered such explosive comments.
Jalil is far from being the only radical imam in America's prison system. Stephen Schwartz, writing last week in the Weekly Standard, believes that "radical Muslim chaplains . . . acting in coordination to impose an extremist agenda . . . have gained a monopoly over Islamic religious activities in American state, federal, and city prisons and jails."
Moderate Muslim prisoners are complaining that radical chaplains subject them to humiliation, discrimination, and even physical threats. "Imagine," he says, "each prison Islamic [prison] community as a little Saudi kingdom behind prison walls, without the amenities. They have effectively induced American authorities to establish a form of 'state Islam'" in correctional systems, Schwartz says.
Over the years at Prison Fellowship, Chuck has asked many inmates, chaplains, and officers why Islam is growing so fast. First, they say that inmates consider Christianity a white man's religion, and Islam a black man's religion. Second, they say the brotherhood of Islam appeals to them because it invites them into a whole way of living that is different. They talk about Islam as a whole life system--which, by the way, points out that as Christians we must do a better job of presenting Christianity as a whole way of life.
We've already seen some frightening examples of what can happen when radical Muslims play on the sensibilities of prisoners who feel isolated and vulnerable. Muktar Said Ibrahim, who is believed to be the ringleader in the attempted bombing of London's subway system last summer, converted to Islam in prison. So did "shoe bomber" Richard Reid.
We need to heed the warnings of Patrick Sookhdeo, a Muslim convert to Christianity. Sookhdeo is the author of a book titled Islam: The Challenge to the Church. In it, he warns that Islam, "alone among world faiths, has very clear-cut aims for reorganizing society to conform to its teaching. Because of this, Muslim minorities are impacting their host societies in the West in a way which no other faith is doing"--and that's including in America's prisons.
Clearly, prison authorities must be more vigilant and adopt strict measures to guard against the spread of radical Islam that teaches violence and hate. In particular, they must remove radical imam chaplains who incite terrorism. But as Christians we must do our job, as well. We need to increase our own loving presence among prisoners--people who are often lonely and desperate.
In prison, like everywhere else, the surest antidote to the poison of hatred is the message of love--the message of the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
This definitely got me thinking. How do Christians respond, and how does the state respond? Certainly very differently. As Christians, we need to be way more active in jails. And Christianity doesn't need to be a soft-lovey faith either. It's turned into that the past several decades, but it's really not a soft, cuddly faith. I can imagine it's hard for prison inmates to take a faith that's packaged to be all about being emotional and soft. Christianity can be a manly faith, too. It has been for centuries. As Christians we need to be active in sharing the gospel about a God who is our "mighty fortress" and a "bulwark never failing." To be honest, we are in competition with people like Umar Abdul-Jalil. What bothered me most was this quote: "Muslim minorities are impacting their host societies in the West in a way which no other faith is doing." It's time for the hosts to do the impacting upon their guests. Not the other way around. Otherwise, we'll end up looking like Europe. This is the most prime turf - our territory, and we're being foolish not to be proactive about fighting on our turf. We need to be in these prisons sharing the gospel, and I praise people like Mark Earley for doing that.
Politically, I'm not sure how we should respond to this. What Abdul-Jalil said is protected by free speach. There's no reason what he said should not be covered by it. But we also need to realize that it's people like him who is recruiting Richard Reid shoebombers and Muktar Said Ibrahim subway bombers. What Abdul-Jalil said is not a danger to the state. But what he's purposely producing is. I'm not sure what we should do about that.
Any comments?
6 comentarios:
You're right mate, what he's saying is covered under the freedom of speech. However, it could probably be argued that his right to say that is his personal freedom of speech, as an individual and on his own time. While working as a government employee, he may receive less free speech protection. He should be fired for inciting ethnic and religous hatred while on the government payroll.
If you want to get involved with prison ministry, my grandma goes to the state prisons very regulary to visit inmates. If you want to go up sometime this summer, I'm sure she'd be more than willing to take you along - I can hook you up with her if you're interested or even if you just want to talk to her about the subject in general.
Oh yea? Around where we live? Does she do it on her own or with a group? That's really sweet. I'm not gonna be around much of the summer (due to Europe, and then coming back earlier to school for RA training), but I'd be interested in looking into it while I'm home. We have a prison ministry here at school, and the guy who leads it just spoke a few weeks ago, and I thought it was really cool, and I've been considering doing it.
Of course you'll disagree with me, but I'm with this guy on the biggest terrorists in the world being in the White House, not some cave in Afghanistan.
Haha. Well, I'm not a uncritical supporter of Bush. There's plenty of stuff he does that I just think is plain dumb. But yea, I can't agree with the guy. I think that's a little too far. Even if Bush's idea to go into Iraq was a horribly wrong idea - ridiculously stupid - I still see no moral or motivational equivalency to terrorist attacks. I think it would be absolutely ridiculous and irrational to think that Bush is trying to kill as many citizens as possible. There's no justification for that viewpoint whatsoever. But Osama bin Ladin, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, and Ayman al-Zawahri want to kill as many citizens as possible, and they don't even care whether they are Americans or Arabs (i.e. Iraqis).
No, the major terrorist organizations of the world are not out to kill as many people as possible. That's the view advanced by governments (ie the Bush administration) that need their populaces to be terrified of hordes of bloodthirsty foreign savages in order to push agendas that would otherwise be soundly opposed. Terrorists, like governments, have political agendas. Generally, terrorism occurs when people have tried to advance their agendas peacefully, and have been completely ignored by those in power. Governments do the same thing, except because they're governments and have better PR machines, they can get away with bombing helpless nations into rubble and calling it a "peacekeeping action".
Terrorism is the practice of instilling fear into your opponents in order to make them do what you want them to do. Those in power the world over are very practiced at doing this to maintain their rule over everyone else, and making everyone else think it's for their own good in the process.
Well, I did realize later a little mistake in what I said. I would concede that terrorists don't want to kill as many people as possible, blanket statement. Bin Laden, for example, has offered his peace treaties with the American people and stated his opposition to Bush specifically. Even though I'm skeptical beyond words of any treaty bin Laden would offer (I believe that he wants nothing less than a global Islam, and he'll do whatever it takes to get that, including faking treaties with "the people"), I believe there's some legitimacy behind his statement. He won't kill as many Americans as possible if he doesn't have to, but he still specifically targets civilians. George Bush and the U.S. government does not systematically target civilians. Nor does he/it want to. Yes, civilians die in U.S. strikes, but the U.S. government is not flying airplanes into buildings just to kill civilians. We are not strapping bombs to people to blow up cafes. Terrorists do not attempt to advance their agendas peacefully first. They show resolute unwillingness to lay down their arms and diplomatically negotiate. Of course governments push their own agendas - I'm a realist at heart. States seek their interest and only their interest. But I've also got a little bit of Kantian idealism in my beliefs, too. I feel states are lot safer than terrorists. At least government rulers have to face their constituents. Terrorists got nothing to lose. They're much more dangerous.
Publicar un comentario