"When the Zionists behave like there are no rules and no red lines and no limits to the confrontation, it is our right to behave in the same way,"-Sheik Hassan Nasrallah, Hezbollah leader
Dude. Let me get this straight....you kidnapped two Israeli soldiers out of the blue. After several years of peace between Lebanon and Israel, you just randomly kidnap soldiers. Dude, what the heck are you talking about Israel acting as if there are no rules or red lines. The entire world is going to think you're a retard now. Maybe you could get the French to believe you, but that's it. Nice try man. Nice try.
9 comentarios:
Mmm...they are not as ridiculous claims as you might think. Yes, the two (not one) soldiers were kidnapped after Israel had been bombing Palestinian territory. Hamas had been responding to the attacks and Hezbollah thought it would be a good idea to help Hamas. It was Israel, as a terrorist state, that started the fully-fledged attacks and blockades in Lebanon. So, yes, it is their right to strike back--even with Irani and Syrian help.
So what that Irani guards were in North Korea? Both countries are recognized by the UN and are sovereign.
-Inti Martinez
Oh yea, good call on the number of soldiers. That's what I meant, but for some reason I accidentally typed it singular.
As for the actual situation, that's giving the militants WAY too much credit. By all means, I am not a hardcore conservative who supports Israel, no questions asked. I think Israel has a lot to be blamed about, and I think their response has been entirely irresponsible and inappropriate by making the entire populations suffer. I think it's both wrong, as well as unwise and unproductive (and probably counter-productive) strategically.
However, Hamas had not been responding to attacks. Israel did exactly what most Palestinians have been asking for - one year ago, Israel started withdrawing all of their troops from Gaza. Israel did absolutely NOTHING to provoke the kidnapping. In fact, just the opposite, they were showing a willingness to work with the Palestinian people and provide them with self-autonomy and an unoccupied land. But Hamas blew it. There's not arguing about it. Hamas utterly failed in the peace process. As one columnist put it, Hamas never loses an opportunity to lose an opportunity. Again, I think Israel needs to be reprimanded for their irresponsible behavior in response to both cases, but it must not be forgotten that both Hamas and Hezbollah provoked these Israeli retaliations. As for Hezbollah "helping out" Hamas, what in the world do they have to do with the situation in Gaza? Absolutely nothing. They have no reasoning for getting involved in this, except that they just wanted to provoke the situation and cause upheaval and unrest in the area. These groups have no legitimacy in their action. Israel has at least some.
So what that Iranian guards were in North Korea? I don't know what the relevancy of UN comment was...what were you getting at?
It's a big deal because there was never any such link between the two before. I just assumed they were two unconnected issues - two countries that the entire rest of the world was incredibly worried about. It's scary now because North Korea already has the technology and Iran has the guts to use it. I'm not convinced that Kim Jong Il wants anything but attention, so we don't have to worry about him too much. Iran is who we have to worry about, and if NK with the technology is associated with Iran, than we've got a lot to be concerned about.
Let´s stick to the evidence and the actual timeline. I know you want this too:
¨War erupted between Hezbollah and Israel after the Lebanese
militia launched Operation Truthful Promise against
Israel by crossing the border and capturing two Israeli
soldiers. The operation was staged in response to Operation
Summer Rains, in which Israel occupied Gaza and destroyed
a large portion of the civilian infrastructure. Israel
countered Operation Truthful Promise by staging Operation
Just Reward against Lebanon, bombing roads, bridges, power
stations, fuel depots, ports, and airports, and killing
numerous civilians. Hezbollah bombed Haifa, surprising
Israel with the range of its rockets and killing at least
eight civilians.¨--borrowed from Harper´s Magazine.
The Arab and Muslim world, as a whole, has legitimacy in everything that goes on in their region. Hezbollah might not have immediate legitimacy in helping Hamas, but they are together on a same cause: resisting Israel and getting them out of the Middle East. I think this is the bottomline and every country, including Iran and Syria, have legitimacy in fighting for this cause.
The problem is that even though they might have legitimacy, it might not be a good idea to strike directly back at Israel. Israel is a client state of the US and will be supported by the US everytime, all the time.
North Korea and the Dear Leader don´t just want attention (that´s part of it--a strategy), they are also interested in developing WMD with delivery capability in order to deter the US and it´s allies. Possessing WMD (of any kind--preferably nuclear) is the only way to deter outlaw states like the US. The US knows this full well and, instead of disarming, according to the NPT, they beefed up their nuclear arsenal to deter other outlaw states. Iran and others are interested in doing the same thing in order to accomplish their goals (including combating imperialism and Israel).
I am not sure how awesome this whole thing is going to get, but I can assure you that a nuclear war will be seen within our lifetime if things continue like this.
Also, according the most recent and credible polling centers in the world, the US is considered the single greatest threat to world peace. NK and Iran are just reactionary centers and do not push (yet) a leadership agenda in nuclear proliferation, terrorism, and imperialism like the US does.
-Inti Martinez
I don't feel like typing too much right now, having to get up early tomorrow morning.
But, the timeline certainly stops quite short. "Israel occupied Gaza and destroyed a large portion of the civilian infrastructure" only after they had already pulled out, shown their willingness to move towards an autonomous Palestine, and subsequently been provoked by the Hamas kidnapping of the Israeli soldier.
Do Palestinian militants want autonomy or not? Time and again Israel takes steps to move towards granting the Palestinians peace, but the militants blow it everytime. It's a striking irony that the militants, who Palestinian automony, are the sole reason for Israel constantly reoccupying Palestinian land. If the militants would just for once stop intentionally provoking the lion, they would actually get what they claim they want. Or do they really want to "wipe Israel of the map"? If they do, then Israel has a right to defend itself by all means, I think. I truly don't know what the militants really want, but they keep ruining their chance for autonomy.
If all the Arab countries have legitimacy in fighting for the cause of driving Israel out of the Middle East because they have "legitimacy in everything that goes on in their region", then how can the US be blamed for all of its intermingling in its backyard in Latin America? That's being inconsistent in your claims. The US, by principle then, should have legitimacy in everything that goes on in its region, including snuffing out communist revolutions, supporting dictators and assasinating revolutionaries. You can't blame the US for doing that and simultaneously support Iran and Syria in their puppeteering Hezbollah and Hamas to drive Israel out of the Middle East. It's contradictory.
I support Israel in its defence, but I simultaneously condemn its attacks upon innocent civilians (and even the Lebanese government). I think it is both immoral - they have nothing do with the conflict - and impractical - it only causes more hatred of Israel (and not of the militant groups like Israel wants).
Hezbollah currently has over 10,000 rockets, so attacking them until disablement is not practical. Syria and Iran are the roots of the issue both for Hamas and Hezbollah, and the entire world needs to focus in on these two countries.
And of course the U.S. is considered the number one threat to world peace. That's the story of history: the one at the top is always the most dangerous, because they have the power. The weaker ones would do the same thing if they were in power. Heck, even France would. The only reason they're all pussy-peace is because it's they know it's the only way that they can get what they want. If force was the best way they could get what they want, they'd use that. Same with Iran, Syria, and North Korea. Who do you want on top as the most powerful? It doesn't matter. They'll all be the aggressor, "threatening world peace" as all the other countries attempt to challenge their hegemony.
The US is considered the single greatest threat to world peace? Good. I feel a lot safer than if Iran or North Korea was in the position to be considered the single greatest threat to world peace.
I would much rather have a secular state like the U.S. be in the hegemonic position capable of most "threatening world peace" than some Islamic extremist country led by the Supreme Leader, or some wacked communist psycho who kills his own people.
I'm a realist all the way. Somebody's gotta be in charge and I think the world is a safer place with America being in charge than Iran or North Korea.
I think you bearly know what I think of US-Latin America relations to judge and say that my claims are contradictory and inconsistent. Also, I don't think you know enough about "communist" leaders in Latin America or about the region's history in general. You will probably respond by saying that you were tired or too late to think straight.
Your analogy of US:LatAm::Iran:Middle East is oversimplified and myopic. There have never been real and direct threats to the US from the part of Latin America. There is no one country that is threatening the whole western hemisphere for the US to attack or invade it. The US claims this country is Cuba, but evidence shows that this is not true. If the US would really want to help our region, it would need to intervene diplomatically and logistically, and not militarily, in order to help the region develop. Israel does threaten the Middle East.
No one argues that NK and Iran as leaders in the world would be worse than the US, slightly. You probably have to study more about US history and research official documents detailing the "hegemonic benevolence" of the US. Try reading Noam Chomsky.
Have a good summer!
-Inti Martinez
1) I don't claim tiredness at all. I was in a coherent state of mind and I still stand behind all I said. True, I have never heard your detailed views specifically on US-Latin America relations. But from all the views I have heard you state about the US and Latin America, I felt I was pretty safe assuming you to be grouped with the standard liberal view (which by your subsequent statements about what appropriate US action in LA would be, seem to support my suspicions), which would then be contradictory to your view on the legitimacy of Iranian and Syrian involvement
2)Stating that Israel is a direct threat to the Middle East is the most absurd statement I have heard out of this whole situation. I have yet to hear anyone else state that. I haven't even heard the Arab nations try and argue that. How in the world is Israel a threat to the Middle East? They just want to live in peace if these militant groups would just freaking leave them alone. When has Israel demonstrated imperialism excluding the times when it was in direct response to an Arab attack? If the Arabs would just let Israel be, Israel would just let the Arabs be! Look at Lebanon and Gaza! Israel removed the troups from these areas in an attempt to provide autonomy and peace. What do the militants do? Kidnap Israeli soldiers off of Israeli ground and lob rockets into Israel territory. Israel continually shows no sign of threatening anywhere or anyone until they are attacked. Where does Israel have a stated policy of whiping Arab countries off the map like Iran or militants proudly boast of Israel? That is utterly absurd to argue that Israel is a threat to the Middle East. Islamofascists are a threat to the Middle East.
3)I'm not sure if I understand you correctly....are you saying that nobody in the world thinks that Iran or NK hegemony would be worse than US hegemony? If so:
I do not claim the US to be the righteous country that does no wrong. "Hegemonic benevolence" is one of the last words I would ever use to describe the US. The US has done horrible, wretched things in its past and continue to do so. But you know what? It's still better than what NK or Iran would do. Good grief! Those two leaders barely have a grasp on sanity! How can you possibly think the world would be safer if they were in control? You haven't been reading too much if you say that "No one argues that NK and Iran as leaders in the world would be worse than the US." Practically the entire world (save some eastern countries who are being soft due to their own economic interest) is united in keeping these lunatics from being in any position to do damage. All of Europe, for example, is worried to death about both of these countries.
Dude, even the French warned that they would nuke Iran in the worst case scenario.
I see absolutely no basis for your claims that 1) Israel is a threat to Middle East, and 2) The world would prefer Iran or NK hegemony over US hegemony (I think that's what your saying???)
Study and read more, then we can talk. Too many sound bites but no argument. Try not to repeat all you hear and read on the news media and commentators. It sounds too goofy.
-Inti Martinez
Good argument, Inti.
And thank you for your condescension to my ignorance and naivete Oh Wise One. Way to base the conclusion of your argument on the fact that I'm an uneducated ass that doesn't know anything. That'll win arguments!
so what are we to read, inti? Chomsky, and most likely Zinn, i gather? Who else? i have followed this thread, but do understand what you are talking about.
You use language and arguments that are inaccesible --especially to those of us who are spoon fed sound bites off Fox News. i can follow you on military operations and such, but as afar as a motivating argument, i don't see what you saying. So, in plain speak, what are you getting at?
Publicar un comentario